Is civil disobedience a moral responsibility of a citizen. E2H: Justice and Culture — Argumentative Writing Prompt on Civil Disobedience 2019-01-23

Is civil disobedience a moral responsibility of a citizen Rating: 6,7/10 368 reviews

Civil Disobedience: A Necessary Freedom

is civil disobedience a moral responsibility of a citizen

The ultimate impact of more recent acts of civil disobedience — anti-abortion trespass demonstrations or acts of disobedience taken as part of the environmental movement and animal rights movement — remains to be seen. He maintained that the common people had the right and duty to disobedience and rebellion if state officials ruled contrary to the Bible. Justifications for civil disobedience were clearly related to the type of methods used. Smith believes that civil disobedience can be useful even if the the public sphere is functioning normally, while the German philosopher asserts that if the public sphere is accessible and the government is responsive, no disobedient acts will be needed. An exception might be where a person's breach is sufficiently minor, such as jaywalking, that concealment is unnecessary since sanction is unlikely to follow. The task of defending civil disobedience is commonly undertaken with the assumption that in reasonably just, liberal societies people have a general moral obligation to follow the law.


Next

Civil Disobedience: When Law

is civil disobedience a moral responsibility of a citizen

There are at least three possible replies. Perhaps coming to a site like this to see how the other side thinks. The cross was the price Jesus paid for the ultimate act of civil disobedience. Turing to a consideration of liberalism, April said that, to oversimplify somewhat, it presupposed reasoned debate, peaceful and nonviolent political means to achieve change - hence political meetings, elections and so forth. However, it was not until the launch of a massive civil disobedience campaign in 1965 that the Voting Rights Act gained real traction The Voting Rights Act. For instance, the 1960 Signet Classics edition of Walden included a version with this title. Thoreau 1817-1862 writer made the theory, put it in practice, and gave the practice a name civil disobedience.

Next

Civil Disobedience: A Necessary Freedom

is civil disobedience a moral responsibility of a citizen

However, some contend that Hobbes and Creon are wrong in this last assumption. So the universal one was thinking of was not merely a theory but represented some kind of ideal society, with even an incipient organisation. The entire point of civil disobedience is to show how unjust it is to punish a person who breaks an unjust law. Did the concept of world citizenship have any meaning? But Bob was right in saying that she was not including a sense of the sacred, and this was true not only of this paper but of her more general thinking. The difference in communication between the civil disobedient and the ordinary offender reflects a deeper difference in motivation for breaching the law Brownlee 2012. This situation raises the question of civil disobedience: when is a Christian justified in disobeying the law? Kant believes that the public sphere can fulfill its purpose solely through freedom of speech and scholarly discourse, and that the merits of a particular idea can be persuasively conveyed through writing.

Next

The Pros and Cons of Civil Disobedience :: Civil Disobedience Essays

is civil disobedience a moral responsibility of a citizen

Justice, according to Thoreau, does not and should not rely on the ruling majority. While the actions of Martin Luther King, Junior should certainly be applauded, we must look to two instances in which the legal channels were far more beneficial. Iraq, civil disobedience is a harmful shortcut that many cynics unfortunately resort to. April agreed that the appeal to a general spiritual sense was extremely important for Gandhi. Gandhi, as April had noted, had drawn on anarchist, liberal and republican traditions, But he drew also on the religious element.


Next

Civil Disobedience: When Law

is civil disobedience a moral responsibility of a citizen

First, the causes which prompt people to take up civil disobedience - such as nuclear weapons, or environmental concerns. When this happens the very many people who benefit from the status quo will fight to keep it as is. If you did things for yourself as a world citizen, then national boundaries were not very important. In international relations it was linked to dissatisfaction with various models of international society, particularly the strongly realist model which emphasised the exclusive, or almost exclusive role of nation states. Moreover, as a matter of prudence, non-violence does not carry the same risk of antagonising potential allies or confirming the antipathy of opponents Raz 1979, 267. Before pursuing that, there was the question of how far liberalism or republicanism could meet the obvious need for an international dimension. Gandhi justified that position not simply in terms of the issue but in terms of a social process.

Next

Civil Disobedience: A Necessary Freedom

is civil disobedience a moral responsibility of a citizen

Civil disobedience sometimes serves primarily to inform and to educate the public about an issue. The whole humanist tendency in the present century was based on a different premise and there were many people who would feel there were basic human rights without subscribing to a religious view. Citizens might wish that their governments would do some or all of these things for them. In India, Gandhi had some success in this project. In a representative democracy the people who are elected to office do not have a clue as to why they were elected in the first place.


Next

Civil Disobedience: A Necessary Freedom

is civil disobedience a moral responsibility of a citizen

Such a conception allows that civil disobedience can be violent, partially covert, and revolutionary. It is equally important that she choose that action for the right reasons. Does a constant cycle of law breaking with personal vindication ensue? Many faced beatings, imprisonment, and even death for pursuing a change and a revolution. There was a strong appeal to individual conscience with religious overtones in some of the rhetoric. But that man the city places in authority, his orders must be obeyed, large and small, right and wrong.

Next

Civil Disobedience Can Be Justified

is civil disobedience a moral responsibility of a citizen

Discipleship includes accurately applying all that Jesus taught, whether personally or through His apostles. In the years leading up to 1965, such legislation had the support of numerous politicians and thinkers, including Martin Luther King. Oxford University Press, 2005 p. There were of course times when you had no option but to register your individual objection - everything in you demanded it. Some broader accounts of civil disobedience offered in response to Rawls's view Raz 1979; Greenawalt 1987 will be examined in the first section of this entry. Certainly, nonviolence is always preferable to violence, but we may have a greater difficulty in arguing that all forms of injustice and violent oppression can be dissolved nonviolently.


Next