His reputation in America was so great that the most important writers of the era, including Ralph Waldo Emerson, Oliver Wendell Holmes, Sr. But as time passes, he becomes more and more obsessed with it. Again, this also relates to the thesis statement about how this is an allegory. Instead of seeing it as a mark of uniqueness, he sees it as an imperfection. A writer has choices to make when it comes to the view point. Imagine if the person you loved couldn't stop talking about how unattractive your face was! He sees it as a flaw in an other wise perfect woman. Throughout the story, Hawthorne shows that using science to control nature is impossible.
They were told to believe that the male, their husband was the ruler of the house. The role of Georgiana in The Birthmark takes on one of the traditional subservient woman of the time. Aminadab laughs again—earth celebrating its victory over the spiritual. What were they rebelling against? Georgiana represents the closest state to perfection that man can aspire to but Aylmer is not content. Language occurs in this stage because as the person is able to differentiate between the self and others he or she struggles to define the differences with words.
Aylmer has devoted his life to his scientific work, and would never leave the world of science. The opening introduces the central themes of the story, setting a scene in which scientists are already trying to control nature and claim dangerous power for themselves. Instead of seeing Aylmer as evil and striving for ultimate perfection or reading into the evils or dangers of science, the reader sees Aylmer as a more humane, regular person in the Symbolic stage searching to find unity in the Real stage. He's a scientist and, like the authors in the Age of Reason, believes that science can fix anything. The theme of religion is hidden in the desire to erase Maybe people think so—thousands have cosmetic surgery performed every year as a way of trying to make themselves more beautiful. Language is a signifier that triggers the signified, but Lacan only acknowledges the signifier.
Earth's Holocaust is his most striking statement of the theme, but every story and novel is based on that premise. Judith Fetterley claims that Nathaniel Hawthorne wrote The Birthmark to be a commentary on feminism, and how the way women view themselves is directly affected by the way the men in their lives. The presence of her birthmark causes Kate to be shy and self-conscious. His entire self-worth is invested in the result of this experiment. If you are, then you should feel at home as a member of human kind. Hawthorne also uses Aylmer and the hand-shaped birthmark as symbols of this conflict and its resolution. It is in the shape of a tiny hand, such as one of a fairy.
Although, she reads his journals and finds out that all his experiments never quite reach their full goal. This analogy is not incidental, the three stories are all, to some extent, revisions of the Garden of Eden tale. Georgiana faints, and Aylmer calls for Aminadab, his assistant, to help him. This story reveals the pursuit of perfection in a world where it is non-existent. Does this man perhaps deserve a touch of human sympathy? Aylmer seems oblivious to any such loss. Hawthorne uses the narrative to show the world that humans are mortal beings, and that no person is knowledgeable enough to assume the role of an all-powerful god.
There is a phase in a marriage where you can either accept a flaw, or attempt to correct it. In some ways, there is almost too much foreshadowing going on in this short story by Nathaniel Hawthorne. Falling Action Without hesitation Almyer comes up with a potion which he believes will cure Georgiana and make her perfect. Without the attainment of knowledge, man would still be in a primitive state. This time was marked by an increase in scientific work and discoveries in Europe, and it overlapped with the European Enlightenment in the eighteenth century. Therefore, women were either dependent on their father or husband. However, his pride blinds him to the fact that his own experiments with the birthmark might have moral implications, as well.
Hawthorne even tells the reader, that her birthmark was a symbol in the story. Georgiana, a flawed individual, attempts to obtain a perfect flower, but instead causes the flower to die, for Georgiana's touch represents the imperfections inherent in all human beings. Georgiana, for example can be viewed as someone who was confident and self-assured with her birthmark but later on became miserable with it after she knew that her husband disliked it. Most medical practices are beneficial; they are done to cure people from illness and to save people's lives. When he returns to the inner room of his laboratory, Georgiana realizes she forgot to tell him about a strange feeling in the birthmark which has made her restless, so she follows him. Because of his desire to remove the imperfection from his wife or he just wanted to prove what he was capable of, he did not notice that he was already ruining the life of his wife. What would a person risk to please the one that they love? You are, of course, free to add your own analysis and understanding of the plot or themes to them for your essay.
As Georgiana studies the various aspects of her husband's profession she finds herself captivated by what he can do. If that fail us we are ruined. However, in the story they wanted to get rid of it. He did not portray the main characters: Aylmer, Georgiana, and Ambidab as human beings, but rather as symbols. The main element of the stories that will be compared is this thought of an operation.